Yardbarker
x
How Ben Simmons' season of the future makes him Rookie of the Year today
Simmons' ROY Award is symbolic of a league seeing a glimpse of its future in his season. Kyle Ross/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

How Ben Simmons' season of the future makes him Rookie of the Year today

Not only are rookie seasons allegories, they are the auspicious fulfillment of allegories. They will eventually become a part of a time capsule that we’ll use to help remember what yesterday was like as they forge a new future in a league so concerned with the present. So much about today’s NBA is about how long the Warriors can extend their league-wide dominance and what LeBron James’ omnipresent brilliance means among the canon of transcendental luminaries.

What made Ben Simmons the Rookie of the Year over Donovan Mitchell is the sense that what he brings to the league is a metaphorical look into its future, a linear progression in the trend of moving away from epimorphic positionality. No longer are players born into a position, but the ability to slide into the role that best fits the team in any given situation. Ben Simmons, a 6-10 point guard with the finishing ability of a modern power forward and the length to defend anyone in between, gave us a first look at how Philly intends on finding its own seat at the table among the elite.

While Simmons goes back to Philly with the award, Mitchell’s season pushed the boundaries of what a race for such an arbitrary award could look like. Simmons spent a year breaking a priori assumptions about expected skill sets while Mitchell relied on familiar tropes, but that familiarity helped Utah find the kind of energy needed to navigate a brutal Western Conference expected to eat the team alive.

Watching Ben Simmons assiduously pick his spots contrasted against Mitchell’s exhibitionistic performances may have been the most fascinating contrasting of styles for a pair of rookies vying for this award in quite some time. In so many ways, they’re valued equally by their teams — young studs charged with taking a new era of their franchise to heights unimagined until they set foot on the floor.

For Simmons, the story is just as important as the production. These 76ers intentionally produced bad basketball in hopes of landing a point-forward with the ability to augment an offense — even without the ability to shoot from distance. The future of Philly is firmly in the hands of a player without the single most important contemporary skillset, and yet he still played above and beyond nearly all of his peers.

Simmons became the first rookie since Oscar Robertson to average at least 15-8-8, the first since Magic Johnson to exceed these totals before his 22nd birthday and just the seventh player ever — regardless of age — in NBA history. Every player who has reached these numbers in a single season is either in the Hall of Fame now or will be when he retires. Simmons is no doubt a generational player who should be celebrated and honored for an exceptional first year on court.


Gene Sweeney Jr./Getty Images

Mitchell’s story, on the other hand, just didn’t have the teeth to hold onto us for the entirety of the season. The Jazz were expected to take a year off and rebuild with the loss of Gordon Hayward, and for the first month or so, Mitchell played well, but wasn’t pulling voters away from Simmons' campaign until mid-December. On the same week that Simmons notched his third career triple-double, Mitchell was in the midst of a scoring binge that pushed his average to 26 points per contest.

Mitchell wasn’t just recording huge, empty numbers, he was pouring it in on a team that was winning on the strength of his ability to take on the scoring load. By the end of January and spilling into the beginning of February, Mitchell was earning a reputation as one of the best combo guards in the NBA as the Jazz recorded an 11-game and a nine-game winning streak over a 23-game stretch.

While the Rookie of the Year award felt like it was Simmons to lose from the jump, Mitchell played like a man not willing to wait to see if he’d lose it. His +/- splits by month grew from +10.7 in February to +15.9 in March to an insane +26.4 in the six games Utah played in April.

Unfortunately for Mitchell, Simmons was just as brilliant as the season progressed, and led the 76ers to a 16-game winning streak to close out the season and give them the No. 3 seed in the Eastern Conference. During that streak, with Joel Embiid out for the majority of that stretch, Simmons nearly averaged a triple-double with 14 points, 10.4 assists and 9.8 rebounds while shooting .591 from the field on 10 shots per contest.

The day before the 76ers began their run, they were the 6th seed in the East with three teams within a game of each other fighting for the final two spots with about a month left. If Simmons doesn’t elevate his game, especially with an injured Embiid, there is a very real chance that this team doesn’t play in the postseason.

The distance between Simmons and Mitchell is the auspicious fulfillment of allegory. After year one for both players, one could not discern with any kind of objective truth who the better basketball player is because what they bring to the table is so wildly different. But after year one, it’s Simmons whose season felt like tomorrow, which is why he’s the ROY today.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

+

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.